Peter Young
17 December 1999
England Football Online
Contact Us Page Last Updated 17 December 1999
These opinion pieces express only the views of the author of the particular piece.


Comment: Shearer: Captain in Name Only

  Despite their occasional use of the editorial "we," they do not necessarily represent the views of the other authors of this website.
Why Kevin Keegan must replace Alan Shearer as captain

We've all seen it, England captain Alan Shearer's customary celebration after he scores.  Arm raised, he wheels away from the goal--and always in a direction that takes him away from the player who has made the scoring opportunity for him.   This, of course, ensures that the television camera and the crowd in the stands stay focused on him and him alone.  Eventually, after the celebration subsides, he might give a nod to the playmaker, but by then the moment of glory has passed.

Against Luxembourg in September, Kieron Dyer made a run down the right, got clipped by a defender but still managed to send in a low centring pass for a Shearer goal before falling to the pitch injured.  Since Dyer was a 20-year-old making his England debut and Shearer's team-mate at Newcastle United, one would have expected his captain's first thought would be to come over to congratulate him on his effort if not to see whether he was alright.  But, no, while Dyer lay writhing on the ground to the right of the goal, his captain and team-mate wheeled away to the left in celebration, literally turning his back to Dyer.  

It was left to elder statesman Stuart Pearce to sprint some 70 yards from his left back position to aid and comfort Dyer.  Pearce, himself a former England captain, knows what a captain's role is.  Shearer does not.  

Shearer has never provided the leadership a captain should.  It doesn't make things easier that he has as much charisma as a wet dish rag.  One can imagine an effective captain who has little charisma, a solid, dependable, determined and conscientious sort whose bearing and behaviour command instant respect.  But Shearer is often sullen when things don't go his way and appears temperamentally incapable of rallying his team-mates, much less inspiring them, when they perform poorly, as they often have since World Cup 1998.  

As a forward, Shearer is, of course, in the poorest possible position to provide direction to his team-mates on the pitch, and, at least from appearances, he never does.  On several occasions during England's European Championship 2000 qualifying campaign, a calming and cautioning word from the captain was clearly in order because a player was performing in a manner eventually bound to draw at least a yellow card and possibly a red card.  In fact, several England players have acted like mad dogs loose on the pitch over the past 15 months, and in each instance it was obvious to spectators that a card was was inevitable if they continued playing that way.  Yet no on-the-pitch leadership has been forthcoming from captain Shearer in the face of these continuing discipline problems.

Installed as captain when Glenn Hoddle became manager in 1996, Shearer was a poor choice to begin with, and his performance as captain--or, rather, lack of it--has proven that choice to be a huge mistake.  Worse yet, as long as Shearer stays captain, manager Kevin Keegan will remain reluctant to leave him out of the team or to take him off in favour of a substitute even though his play has not merited a place on the team and has certainly warranted his substitution.  

This is one mistake that is not cast in iron; it can be corrected.  For the good of the team, Keegan must come to grips with the problem, put aside the personal relationship he developed with Shearer while managing Newcastle, and replace him as captain.  England cannot afford Keegan's indulgence in sentimental loyalties not justified on merit.