|
Banaś,
Gadocha, Moore or Shilton's goal? - What
we saw and heard..... |
Gardocha's
free-kick from 25 yards out, after McFarland gave away a foul on
Lubański. David Coleman "Swinging
in!...and touched in!'.. Moore stretches for the ball on the
6 yard-line, and just behind him is Banaś, who also stretches for
it. Although the camera's do not ultimately pick up who actually got
the touch, the Polish TV follow Banaś heading back to the centre
"Gardocha with the free-kick!...and it looks as if it was touched by
Banaś!". Later in the first half, Coleman states
"Banaś, whose recall to the national side has proved important!"
As the first half and the second half ended, Coleman again stated
"Polish goal scored by Banaś!" Jimmy Hill also
confirmed:
"There's the scorer there, Banas. The man who crept in past Bobby
Moore. We can see it now, Banas!" |
Banaś,
Gadocha, Moore or Shilton's goal? - What they said..... |
Bobby Moore -
"The ball came in low and fast and their no. 7 and me went for it,
him looking for deflection and me trying to block it. But he didn't
make contact. In fact, I barely got to the ball but I did get a
touch, It spun to the ground and flew up inside the near post of
Shilton's shoulder." Matt Dickinson (Bobby Moore: Man in
Full) - "He was culpable for the first goal after just seven
minutes, straining for a free-kick at the near post and deflecting
it past Peter Shilton." Peter Shilton - "The
ball ricocheted off Bobby's leg, spun ito the ground and flew up in
the air, which caught me out." FA Yearbook: "A
low swerving free kick was taken by Lubański near the left corner flag. The ball flew off Moore's
foot onto the arm of goalkeeper Shilton into the near top corner of the
net." Mike Payne: "It hit Bobby Moore
and then Peter Shilton's hands!" Clive Leatherdale
(Quest For the World Cup): "Gadocha took the kick, bending
the ball viciously towards the near post. The ball flicked Moore,
standing in front of the upright, deflected towards goal and entered
the net off the body of the luckless Peter Shilton."
Stanislaw Bartosik (spectator & Western Journal Editor
in 2013): "It was Banaś who scored. I have no doubt."
Banaś himself stated
(2013) that he was very upset
Gadocha still claims the goal. |
|
|
Match
Summary |
Officials
(black) from Austria |
Poland |
Type |
England |
Referee Paul
Schiller
x (-). |
|
Goal Attempts |
|
|
Attempts on Target |
|
|
Hit Bar/Post |
|
Linesmen |
|
Corner Kicks Won |
|
tbc |
tbc |
|
Offside Calls Against |
|
|
|
Fouls Conceded |
|
|
Possession |
|
|
|
Poland
Team |
|
Rank: |
No official ranking; EFO ranking ELO rating 6th to 4th |
Colours: |
Made by Adidas - White jerseys, red shorts, white socks with
red tops |
Capt: |
Włodzimierz Lubański |
Manager: |
Kazimierz Gorski |
Poland
Lineup |
1 |
Tomaszewski, Jan |
25 |
9 January 1948 |
G |
ŁKS Łódź |
5 |
GA |
2 |
Rześny, Krzysztof |
26 |
2 August 1946 |
RB |
FKS Stal Mielec |
1 |
0 |
3 |
Gorgoń, Jerzy P. |
23 |
18 July 1949 |
LHB |
KS Górnik Zabrze |
|
|
4 |
Musiał, Adam |
24 |
18 December 1948 |
LB |
GTS Wisła Kraków |
|
|
5 |
Bulzacki, Mirosław A. |
21 |
23 October 1951 |
RHB |
ŁKS Łódź |
|
|
6 |
Kraska, Jerzy A. |
21 |
24 December 1951 |
RM |
WKS
Gwardia Warszawa |
|
|
7 |
Banaś, Jan |
30 |
29 March 1943
in Berlin, Germany |
RF |
KS Górnik Zabrze |
|
|
8 |
Ćmikiewicz, Lesław |
24 |
25 August 1948 |
CM |
CWKS
Legia Warszawa |
|
|
9 |
Deyna, Kazimierz |
25 |
23 October 1947 |
LM |
CWKS
Legia Warszawa |
|
|
10 |
Lubański, Włodzimierz L., off injured 54h min
(53:40). |
25 |
28 February 1947 |
CF |
KS Górnik Zabrze |
|
|
11 |
Gadocha, Robert |
27 |
10 January 1946 |
LF |
CWKS Legia Warszawa |
|
|
Poland Substitutes |
15 |
Domarski, Jan A., on 56th min.
(55:20) for Lubański |
26 |
28 October 1946 |
|
FKS Stal Mielec |
|
|
unused substitutes: |
- |
team notes: |
The
Polish team rushed Lubański back into the first team after having
knee surgery and stitches removed only 36 hours priors. As it was,
McFarland's challenge (52:44)
reopened that wound and the injury had to be restitched at the local
hospital. |
|
4-3-3 |
Tomaszewski - Rześny, Bulzacki, Gorgoń, Musiał -
Kraska, Ćmikiewicz, Deyna - Banaś, Lubański (Domarski), Gadocha |
Averages: |
Age |
- |
Appearances/Goals |
- |
- |
|
|
England
Team |
|
Rank: |
No official ranking; EFO ranking ELO rating 3rd |
Colours: |
The 1973
Umbro alternate away uniform - Yellow crew necked aertex
short-sleeved jerseys, blue shorts with yellow side trim, yellow socks.
2nd match, W 0 - D 1 - L 1 - F 1 - A 3³ |
Described by David Coleman as being "Gold",
and also later in the match, as "Lemon"! |
Capt: |
Bobby Moore, 87th captaincy |
Manager: |
Sir
Alfred Ernest Ramsey, 53 (22 January 1920), appointed
25 October 1962, effective part-time 31 December, full from May 1963.
107th
match, W 67 - D 25 - L 15 - F 214 - A 93.¹¹³
team was
named at lunch time |
England
Lineup |
1 |
Shilton, Peter L. |
23 |
18 September 1949 |
G |
Leicester City FC |
11 |
8ᵍᵃ |
2 |
Madeley, Paul |
28 |
20 September 1944 |
RB |
Leeds United AFC |
11 |
0 |
3 |
Hughes, Emlyn W. |
25 |
28 August 1947 |
LB |
Liverpool FC |
24 |
1 |
4 |
Storey, Peter E. |
27 |
7 September 1945 |
RM |
Arsenal FC |
17 |
0 |
5 |
McFarland, Roy L. |
25 |
5 April 1948 |
RHB |
Derby County FC |
17 |
0 |
6 |
Moore, Robert F.C. |
32 |
12 April 1941 |
LHB |
West Ham United FC |
105 |
2 |
7
|
Ball, Alan J. |
28
15 days |
12 May 1945 |
LCM |
Arsenal FC
|
64
|
8
|
second player sent-off for
England |
Ball was sent off in the 77th min. for Violent Conduct. Ball
and Peters had both brought down Ćmikiewicz on the half-way line
(76:05). Ball's reaction to the
Pole trying to kick Peters in the face was to pick him up by his
throat. |
8 |
Bell, Colin |
27 |
26 February 1946 |
RCM |
Manchester City FC |
29 |
4 |
9 |
Chivers, Martin H. |
28
30 days |
27 April 1945 |
RF |
Tottenham Hotspur FC |
20 |
11 |
10 |
Clarke, Allan J. |
26 |
31 July 1946 |
LF |
Leeds United AFC |
11 |
7 |
11 |
Peters, Martin S. |
29 |
8 November 1943 |
LM |
Tottenham Hotspur FC |
60 |
20 |
unused substitutes: |
12-Norman Hunter, 13-Ray Clemence, 14-Tony Currie, 15-Mick Channon,
16-Mike Summerbee. |
|
4-4-2 |
Shilton - Madeley, McFarland, Moore,
Hughes - Storey, Bell, Ball, Peters -
Chivers, Clarke |
Averages: |
Age |
- |
Appearances/Goals |
- |
- |
|
|
Match Report
by Mike Payne |
Sir Alf Ramsey decided on a
4-4-2 formation for this vital World Cup clash and he made it perfectly
clear from the start that England had come to Poland for a point, Alas,
all his pre-match plans came woefully unstuck after only seven minutes.
Roy McFarland was somewhat harshly adjudged to have stopped Lubański
unfairly down the left flank by the Austrian referee. The free-kick was
taken by Gadocha, who hit it low and hard to the near post. It hit Bobby
Moore and then Peter Shilton's hands as the goalkeeper tried
unsuccessfully to keep it out. It was a bitter blow to England and altough
one expected a change in their tactics there was little alteration to the
first half.
England did get a fine chance to equalize only three
minutes after the goal, but Martin Peters headed straight at Tomaszewski
from very close range. Peters really should have scored and England were
to regret his miss. Their only other good chance of the first half came on
the half-hour. A fine move involving Allan Clarke and Colin Bell split the
Polish defence and Martin Chivers was left with the final shot which he
rocketed over the bar from some 12 yards out.
For the most part of the
half, England had persisted with the negative, containing tactics they had
employed from the start. It often left Chivers and Clarke ploughing lonely
furrows up front. Territorially, England probably had the better of the
half but, for all they saw of the ball, the fact was that they could not
score. Just as England had made a disastrous start to the first half,
then so they did at the start of the second. Only one minute had elapsed
after the change round when skipper Moore tried to dribble around Lubański.
Disastrously, he lost possession to the Polish striker and with England's
defence now wide open, Lubański roared on towards Shilton and hit a fierce
low shot past the 'keeper and in off the near post. The massive crowd
screamed their delight and the 2-0 scoreline seemingly put the game out of
England's reach. As the game wore on, there was no sign of an
improvement and the result drifted further and further away from England.
They never managed to create another worthwhile chance and it was
surprising that the manager did not attempt to use any of his substitutes
in trying to rescue the cause. Instead, he persisted with his 4-4-2
formation and ended with nothing.
The final nail in the coffin came
near the end of a bad tempered second half. Ćmikiewicz had already
upset Peters and when he then clashed with Ball the fiery England
midfielder was sent off for violent conduct.
Peter Storey was the star of a very disappointing
performance as he covered every blade of grass in his efforts. Clarke,
too, showed some silky skills and Madeley also showed his class, but other
than that there was little to remember about this showing.
|
Match Report
by The F.A. Yearbook 1973-74, pages 49 & 50 |
This was a
disastrous
match
for England
and hopes of clinching a place in the 1974 World Cup
Finals were devastatingly dispelled by the Poles. England will be very
hard pressed to qualify, in the return game at Wembley on October 17.
The Poles went
ahead after seven minutes through a goal which in most other similar
circumstances would have been prevented. A low swerving free kick was
taken by Lubański near the left corner flag. The ball flew off Moore's
foot onto the arm of goalkeeper Shilton into the near top corner of the
net. England settled down and had more of the play than their opponents
during the remainder of the first half. Chivers, Clarke and Peters had
chances to score, but their attempts to do so were well off target or
easily saved by the Polish goalkeeper. The second half began tragically
for Moore, who allowed Lubański to dispossess him some 30 yards from the
goal-line. With only Shilton to beat Lubański made no mistake. Ball was
sent off with some 12 minutes to play.
|
Match Report
by Norman Giller |
This was a
disastrous defeat for England in a vital World Cup qualifying
match. Poland went ahead in the ninth minute when a Lubański shot
found its way into the net off the foot of Bobby Moore and the arm of
Peter Shilton. Early in the second-half Moore made an uncharacteristic
hash of a tackle against Lubański, who raced clear to make it 2-0. To
compound England's misery Alan Ball was sent off following an angry clash
twelve minutes from the final whistle. Once again, Sir Alf's
poor understanding of the substitute system let down England. It screamed
out for attacking players to be sent on when the Poles went two goals
clear, but Ramsey stuck with his rigid 4-4-2 formation that meant the game
became bogged down in midfield as Poland chose to close up shop and hang
on to their lead.
|
Source Notes |
TheFA.com Original newspaper reports Rothman's Yearbooks
Mike Payne's England: The Complete Post-War Record
(Breedon Books Publishing Company, Derby, U.K., 1993)
Norman Giller, Football Author
____________________
CG
|