The Missed Penalties by Numbers |
Penalties missed at Home |
25
|
Penalties missed Away |
13
|
Penalties
Missed/Saved |
38 |
Penalties Scored |
111 |
Penalties for
England |
149 |
|
The Missed Penalties by Players |
Harry Kane |
4 |
Ernest Needham, Roger Byrne, Franny Lee, David Beckham, Frank Lampard |
2 |
Jimmy Crabtree, Billy Walker, Roy Goodhall, Bill Dean,
Alf Strange, Eric Brook, George Hardwick, Wilf Mannion, Tom Finney, John
Atyeo, Jim Langley, Bobby Charlton, Alan Ball, Allan Clarke, Kevin Keegan,
Trevor Francis, Glenn Hoddle, Gary Lineker, David Platt, Alan Shearer,
Peter Crouch, Jordan Henderson, James Ward-Prowse, unknown |
1 |
|
The Vital Penalties |
Most of the penalty kick misses did not essentially matter to England's
overall score. However, sometimes it did... Had Ernest Needham scored
his penalty on 30 March 1901 against Scotland, it could have resulted in
a victory, although the draw was enough for England to win the Home
Championship for the first time in two years. Had Needham scored
against Wales on 3 March 1902, another victory could have resulted. The
two points would have meant England shared the Championship, and it
would have meant England would have scored in a 53rd consecutive match.
If Roy Goodall had scored from the spot on 28 November 1927, also
against Wales, it could have meant England not being pointless all
season in the Championship. Wilf Mannion may have secured victory for
England against Ireland on 5 November 1947, had he scored, but this had
no bearing on the Home Championship. As could have Bobby Charlton, over
Scotland on 9 April 1960, which would have been the difference between
sharing and winning the Championship. Trevor Francis, Australia on
19 June 1983, and Gary Lineker, over Brazil on 19 May 1992, could have
meant friendly victories. David Beckham could have secured a victory
over Turkey on 11 October 2003, but had no bearing on their European
qualification. It may have been a different tale had he scored his
next miss, against France in Euro 2004. The kick would have sent England
to a two-goal lead with just under twenty minutes to play. Instead,
history had other ideas. Harry Kane had a chance to send England
through to the 2020 European Championship Final with his penalty kick,
he missed, however, he followed up and sent England into the Final. Had
he scored his next miss, also against France, but in the 2022 World Cup
Finals quarter-final, it would have brought England level for a second
time with five minutes left, and then who knows?.... |
When the England Penalties
were Missed |
0-5 |
6-10 |
11-15 |
16-20 |
21-25 |
26-30 |
31-35 |
36-40 |
41-45 +inj |
46-50 |
51-55 |
56-60 |
61-65 |
66-70 |
71-75 |
76-80 |
81-85 |
86-90 |
extra
time |
not
known |
total |
2 |
1 |
5 |
0 |
2 |
0 |
0 |
1 |
4 |
2 |
0 |
2 |
2 |
3 |
4 |
2 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
3 |
37 |
The Nine Pre-War
Penalty-Kicks Missed by England
- "If any player shall intentionally trip put on hold an opposing player, or
deliberately handle the ball within twelve yards from his own goal-line, the
referee shall, on appeal, award the opposing side a penalty kick, to
be taken from any point twelve yards from the goal-line, under the
following conditions:-All players, with the exception of the player
taking the penalty kick and the opposing goal-keeper (who shall not
advance more than six yards from the goal-line) shall stand
at least six yards behind the ball. The ball shall be in
play when the kick is taken, and a goal may be scored from the
penalty kick." - 2 June 1891, Glasgow
"but the ball shall not be again
played by the kicker until it has been played by another player. If
necessary, time of play shall be extended to admit of the penalty kick
being taken." - 13 June 1892, Llandudno
|
1 |
1898-99 |
18 February 1899, 13-2 vs. Ireland,
Roker Park Ground, Sunderland.
27
year-old centre-half Jimmy Crabtree
appears to be the first England player to have missed his penalty-kick,
"the goalkeeper saved. and just turned it
round the post—a wonderful save",
in the 46th minute of his seventh appearance. Although another report
does say he "shot outside". The penalty kick was
awarded after the debuting Irish goalkeeper, James Lewis
'rushed out and threw him down' or
'rushed at him with outstretched arms and toppled him over' as
Gilbert Smith 'was
about to shoot'. |
2 |
1900-01 |
30 March 1901, 2-2 vs. Scotland,
The Sports Arena, Crystal Palace
28
year-old left-half
Ernest Needham
missed his twelfth minute penalty kick
on his fifteenth appearance (after he had scored a
penalty kick in his previous appearance), when he placed the ball directly at Harry Rennie, who had come off his
line 'to the six-yard line' to make the save.
The penalty came about after the referee, James Torrans, witnessed
Barney Battles (some state Jock Drummond) illegally charging
GO Smith within
the twelve yard line. |
- "A
suitable mark shall be made opposite each goal-post, 18 yards from the
goal-line, to assist the Referee in enforcing the regulations as regards
the penalty kick under Law 14.". - 17 June 1901,
Giant's Causeway
|
3 |
1901-02 |
3 March 1902, 0-0 vs. Wales,
The Racecourse, Wrexham
Ernest Needham,
now 29, missed his second penalty kick on his sixteenth
and final appearance, this time against Leigh Roose, who had come off his
line to make the save at the conclusion of the first half. One
report says that Sam
Meredith had fouled Charlie Sagar within the twelve yard line, another
report says that the same player had handled the ball. It also
meant that England failed to score for the first time in 52 matches. |
- "In
the event of any intentional infringement of Law 10 by the defending
side within the penalty area, the Referee shall award the opponents a
penalty kick which shall be taken from the penalty kick mark under the
following conditions ;—All players, with the exception of the
player taking the penalty kick and the opponents' goal-keeper shall be
outside the penalty area. The opponents' goal-keeper shall be within the
goal area. The ball must be kicked forward. The ball shall be in play
when the kick is taken, and a goal may be scored from a penalty kick ;
but the ball shall not be again played by the kicker until it has been
played by another player. If necessary, time of play shall be extended
to admit of the penalty kick being taken.
A free kick shall also be awarded to the opposite side if the ball is
not kicked forward, or is played a second time by the player who takes
the penalty kick, until it has been played by another player." - 16
June 1902, Scarborough
|
4 |
1920-21 |
21 May 1921, 2-0 vs. Belgium, Stade
DC Bruxelles,
Bruxelles
Some textbooks name 28 year-old debutant George
Harrison as the player who missed the twice taken penalty kick against Jan de Bie
at an unknown time. However, no English reporters covered the
match, and Dutch/Belgian reports only state the kick was taken twice,
but not by whom. The name of Harrison came from a now dubious source. |
5 |
1924-25 |
8 December 1924, 4-0 vs. Belgium,
The Hawthorns, West Bromwich
27 year-old inside-left
Billy Walker
had his early penalty kick (c.15th minute) saved by Jan de Bie,
preventing his second England penalty-kick. The kick was awarded
after the debuting Louis Baes 'fisted the
ball out' following a Frank Roberts effort. Despite his miss,
Walker went on to score twice more. |
6 |
1927-28 |
28 November 1927, 1-2 vs. Wales,
Turf Moor, Burnley
24 year-old right-back Roy
Goodall
missed his fiftieth minute penalty kick on his sixth appearance against
Albert Gray after his kick went straight down the centre, allowing Gray
to beat the ball up and subsequently clear. The kick was awarded
for a Bennion 'handball.' |
7 |
1928-29 |
22 October 1928, 2-1 vs.
Ireland,
Goodison Park, Liverpool
21 year-old centre-forward Bill
Dean
had his 21st minute penalty kick saved by Elisha Scott. Making his
eleventh appearance, the penalty was awarded after
Andy McCluggage handled the ball in the area from a Jimmy Ruffell cross.
Dean would go on to score for his country for a seventeenth time. |
8 |
1930-31 |
20 October 1930, 5-1 vs.
Ireland,
Bramall Lane, Sheffield
Thirty year-old right-half
Alf Strange
had his second half penalty kick saved also by Elisha Scott.
Strange was making his fourth appearance. |
9 |
1934-35 |
14 November 1934, 3-2 vs.
Italy,
Arsenal Stadium, Highbury
26 year-old outside-left Eric Brook,
making his tenth appearance, had his first minute penalty kick saved by
Carlo Ceresoli. The Italian goalkeeper had brought down Ted Drake
to give away the penalty-kick. Brook would go on to score twice in the
victory. |
The
Twenty-Eight Post-War
Penalty-Kicks Missed by England
10 |
1 |
1946-47
|
27 November 1946, 8-2 vs. Netherlands,
Leeds Road, Huddersfield
26 year-old
Captain
George Hardwick
hit his 43rd minute penalty
kick straight at Piet Kraak. The pitch was heavy and slippy from the
rainfall. His fourth appearance and yet to register
a goal. |
11 |
2 |
1947-48
|
5 November 1947, 2-2 vs.
Ireland,
Goodison Park, Liverpool
29 year-old
inside-left
Wilf Mannion,
making his eleventh appearance, hit his powerful
seventieth minute penalty kick straight at
goalkeeper Eddie Hinton, who pushed the ball over
the crossbar to preserve Ireland's 1-0 lead.
The penalty was awarded after Stanley Matthews was
sent sprawling by captain Jackie Vernon. Mannion
would get his eighth England goal fourteen minutes
later. |
12-14 |
3-5 |
1955-56
|
30 November 1955, 4-1 vs.
Spain,
Empire Stadium, Wembley
33 year-old
outside-right
Tom Finney,
making his 59th appearance and with 25 England goals
already, had his timid sixth minute penalty kick
saved by Carmelo Cedrún, who was three yards
off his goalline, keeping the match scoreless and
ending a run of seven penalty kicks scored. The penalty was awarded after
Finney
was chasing a John Atyeo ball, to be barged off the
ball by Campanal. Finney would get his 26th goal in
the second half. (2)
9 May 1956, 4-2 vs.
Brazil,
Empire Stadium, Wembley
With the match poised at two
goals each, 24 year-old inside-right
John Atyeo's
62nd minute high blast was brilliantly punched over the
bar by Gilmar, who guessed right in diving to his right. There was two minutes between the award for Zozimo's
handball, and the actual kick, with the Brazilians pushing
and shoving the referee and Alvaro refusing to hand
over the ball. Atyeo was making his second
appearance. Bizarrely, yet
another hand ball by Zozimo led to 26 year-old left-back
Roger Byrne taking the 67th
minute penalty kick with England leading 3-2.
However, despite nineteen appearances, his poorly placed shot along the
ground was saved by Gilmar. |
15 |
6 |
1956-57
|
28 November 1956, 3-0 vs.
Yugoslavia,
Empire Stadium, Wembley
27 year-old left-back Roger Byrne
was now making his 25th appearance, but his 79th
minute penalty kick was placed a foot inside the
post allowing Vladimir Beara to dive and save. The
penalty was awarded after the 35 year-old Branko Stanković
scythed down the 41 year-old Stan Matthews. Not
since 1928 have England missed four consecutive
kicks. |
16 |
7 |
1957-58
|
7 May 1958, 2-1 vs.
Portugal,
Empire Stadium, Wembley
29 year-old left-back Jim
Langley
was now making his second appearance, but his late
left-footed penalty kick hit Carlos Gomes' post,
despite sending the keeper the wrong way. The penalty was
awarded when Ângelo Martins brought down Tom Finney. It
was the fifth successive penalty kick miss in an
England international at Wembley. |
17 |
8 |
1959-60
|
9 April 1960, 1-1 vs.
Scotland,
Hampden Park, Glasgow
22 year-old
Bobby Charlton
had already scored a 49th minute equalizing penalty kick
and was now given the chance to secure victory with
his 75th minute penalty, but
his kick went
straight at goalkeeper Frank Haffey, but the referee ordered it retaken
because of encroachment by Eric Caldow, but some reports also suggest that
Frank Haffey had moved too soon. Either way, Charlton's second effort was
even worse and it went inches wide of the left post. Charlton, making his fifteenth
appearance, remains the only England player to
take three penalty kicks in a single match. |
18 |
9 |
1965-66
|
26 June 1966, 3-0 vs.
Finland,
Olympiastadion, Helsinki
21 year-old
(& 45 days)
Alan Ball
is the youngest player to miss a penalty kick when he
had his fourteenth minute kick saved by goalkeeper Martti Halme,
keeping the match scoreless. Ball was making his
eighth appearance. |
19 |
10 |
1968-69
|
7 May 1969, 2-1 vs.
Wales,
Empire Stadium, Wembley
25 year-old
Franny Lee
had his 21st minute penalty kick strike Gary Sprake's crossbar
denying England an equalising goal. The penalty was
awarded after Peter Rodrigues handled on the
goalline. Lee was making his fourth appearance and
would get his third goal in the second half. |
20 |
11 |
1969-70
|
10 December 1969, 1-0 vs.
Portugal,
Empire Stadium, Wembley
Franny Lee's seventieth minute penalty kick
went about three yards wide of the right hand post. The penalty was awarded
after goalkeeper Rodrigues brought down Jeff Astle.
Histrionic Portuguese protests put off the waiting
Lee, who was making his ninth appearance. |
21 |
12 |
1970-71
|
12 May 1971, 5-0 vs.
Malta,
Empire Stadium, Wembley
24 year-old
Allan Clarke
had already scored a 46th minute penalty kick,
but his sixtieth minute penalty kick was blasted wide of either
Vincent Borg-Bonaci's or substitute Alfred Mizzi's
goal. The penalty was awarded after a Maltese
defender handled Alan Ball's volley on the line.
Histrionic Portuguese protests put off the waiting
Lee, who was making his ninth appearance. |
22 |
13 |
1975-76
|
3 September 1975, 2-1 vs.
Switzerland,
Sankt Jakub Stadium, Basel
24 year-old
Kevin Keegan
had already scored on his fifteenth appearance, four minutes prior to his penalty kick, so
he had
a chance to put his team two up. However, goalkeeper
Erich Burgener had other ideas when he dove to his
right to save Keegan's twelfth minute penalty.
The penalty was awarded after a Burgener brought down David Johnson,
who had been put clear by Colin Bell. |
23 |
14 |
1982-83
|
19 June 1983, 1-1 vs.
Australia,
Olympic Park, Melbourne
29 year-old
Trevor Francis
marked his fortieth appearance with a neatly taken 73rd minute
penalty kick. However, referee Jack Johnstone had
not blown his whistle and so ordered the kick to be
retaken. Francis was not so diligent with this kick
and blazed it over Terry Greedy's crossbar.
The penalty was awarded after a John Kosmina had fouled Terry
Butcher. |
24 |
15 |
1984-85
|
16 June 1985, 5-0 vs.
United States,
Memorial Coliseum, Los Angeles
27 year-old
Glenn Hoddle had his fifteenth
minute penalty kick saved by Arnie Mausser. The
penalty was awarded after Kerry Dixon was fouled. It
was Hoddle's 25th appearance. |
25 |
16 |
1991-92
|
17 May 1992, 1-1 vs.
Brazil,
Wembley Stadium, London
31 year-old Captain
Gary Lineker weak eleventh minute
penalty kick was too easily saved by Carlos Roberto.
The penalty was awarded after the goalkeeper fouled
Lineker. It was Lineker's 76th appearance and if he
had scored, it could have been his 49th goal,
equaling the current record set by Bobby Charlton. |
26 |
17 |
1992-93
|
17 February 1993, 6-0 vs.
San Marino,
Wembley Stadium, London
26 year-old
David Platt was marking his
first match as the new England captain with
extraordinary achievements. His 88th minute penalty
kick was saved by Pier Luigi Benedettini. Had he
scored on his 36th appearance, it would have been
his fifth of the evening, equalling the goalscoring
feat of most goals in a match. The penalty was
awarded after Tony Dorigo was brought down. |
27 |
18 |
1996-97
|
31 May 1997, 2-0 vs.
Poland,
Stadion Śląski, Chorzów
26 year-old Captain
Alan Shearer had already
scored his fifteenth goal in the opening minutes of
his 33rd appearance. His 45th minute penalty kick
struck Andrzej Wozniak's post.
The kick was given when Shearer
was taken down while preparing to shoot after controlling a cross to the
far post from David Batty. |
28 |
19 |
2003-04
|
11 October 2003, 0-0 vs.
Turkey,
Şükrü Saracoğlu Stadyumu, İstanbul
28 year-old Captain
David Beckham slipped and
fell and ultimately skied his 36th minute penalty kick
over Rüstü Reçber crossbar. The
Turkish stadium's pitch lacked a proper drainage system and was
notorious for its soft spots and unreliable footing. The kick was awarded
after Tugay had brought down Steven Gerrard. Beckham was making his 64th
appearance. |
29 |
20 |
2004 European Championship Finals
|
|
13 June 2004, 1-2 vs.
France,
Estádio
do SL Benfica, Lisboa
29 year-old Captain
David Beckham
had his 73rd minute
placed penalty kick well-saved by
Fabian Barthez,
preventing England
taking a 2-0 lead.
The penalty was awarded
after Mikaël Silvestre fouled Wayne Rooney.
Beckham, making his 69th
appearance, is the first
player to miss twice
since Franny Lee in
1969, and only the
fourth player after
Needham and
Byrne. |
30
&
31 |
21 &
22 |
2005-06
|
30 May 2006, 3-1 vs.
Hungary,
Old Trafford, Manchester
27 year-old
Frank Lampard was handed the
penalty responsibilities following Beckham's misses.
However, his 42nd minute
penalty kick was saved to the right hand side of Gábor Király.
The kick was awarded
after Steven Gerrard had been fouled by Csaba Fehér. Lampard was
making his 39th appearance.
3 June 2006, 6-0 vs.
Jamaica, Old Trafford, Manchester
25 year-old
forward
Peter Crouch stepped up to
complete his hattrick. However, his
penalty kick after 82 minutes was hit over
the crossbar. Michael Owen was brought down in the box by Daia Stephenson,
following his weaving run. Making his seventh
appearance, Crocuh did complete his hattrick, seven
minutes later. |
32 |
23 |
2009-10
|
30 May 2010, 2-1 vs.
Japan,
UPC-Arena, Graz Four years to the
day, 31 year-old
Frank Lampard missed his
second penalty kick which was saved by Eiji
Kawashima in the 56th minute. Keisuke Honda's
handball led to England's penalty kick. Honda was in
a wall defending a Lampard free-kick. Lampard was making his
78th
appearance and could have been his twentieth England
goal. |
33 |
24 |
2015-16
|
22 May 2016, 2-1 vs.
Turkey,
Etihad Stadium, Manchester 21 year-old
(& 299 days)
Harry Kane becomes the
youngest player since Alan Ball to miss a penalty
kick when his 72nd minute effort struck Volcan Babacan's right post and went wide.
The penalty was awarded when Mehmut Topal had
brought down the sprinting Jamie Vardy as they both
ran into the penalty area. If Kane had scored
on his eleventh appearance, he would have scored
England's record twelfth penalty kick in a row. |
34 |
25 |
2019-20
|
10 September 2019, 5-3 vs.
Kosovo,
St. Mary's Stadium, Southampton 25 year-old
Captain
Harry Kane becomes the sixth
player to miss two penalty kicks when his 65th minute
effort was saved by Arijanet Murić.
The penalty was awarded when
Ross Barkley
had dribbled into the area and went down following contact with Amir Rrahmani.
Yet again, if Kane had scored, this time
on his 41st appearance, he would have scored
England's record twelfth penalty kick in a row. |
35 |
26 |
2020-21
|
6 June 2021, 1-0 vs.
Romania,
Riverside Stadium, Middlesbrough
Thirty year-old
substitute
Jordan Henderson had his
powerful right-footed 78th minute kick saved by Florin Niţă as he dived to
his right. Awarded by the referee after Tiberiu
Chiriches bundled Dominic Calvert-Lewin over as he received a longpass
from Henderson himself. Henderson was making his
59th appearance and had just taken the armband,
could have been the first England substitute to
score from the spot. |
36 |
27 |
2020 European Championship Finals
|
|
7 July 2021, 2-1 vs.
Denmark,
National Stadium,
Wembley
27 year-old Captain
Harry Kane
had his 104th minute right-footed less than powerful
penalty kick
saved by
Kasper Schmiechel. The
penalty was awarded after Raheem Sterling ran into the area via
the goalline to be bundled over by Joakim Mæhle.
It means that Kane, on
his sixtieth appearance,
becomes the first player
to miss three England
penalty-kicks.
He did, however, follow
up his miss with the
goal that sent England
through to the 202
European Championship
Final. |
37 |
28 |
2021-22
|
9 October 2021, 5-0 vs.
Andorra,
Estadi Nacional, Andorra la Vella
26 year-old
James Ward-Prowse had his
right-footed 79th minute penalty kick saved by Josep Gomes as he dived to
his left. Awarded after Jack Grealish was fouled running into the area
by Chus Rúbio. Ward-Prowse was making his
ninth appearance and he made up for his error by
scoring from the rebound. |
38 |
29 |
2022 World Cup Finals
|
|
10
December 2022, 1-2
vs. France,
Āstād āl-Bayt, Al Khawr
29 year-old Captain
Harry Kane's
penalty in the 84th minute was blazed high above Hugo Lloris' crossbar,
in what could have been
a second equalising
penalty kick
for England in this
match. It was awarded after
Mason Mount, running
onto a Jude Bellingham
through ball was barged
over from an elbow in
the back by Théo
Hernandez.
Kane's 21st penalty kick
for England is his record-extending
fourth miss on his
eightieth appearance. |
|